One of those colleagues is minerva mcgonagall, snape s oldest friend, who is perhaps dearer to him than she yet knows. Severus snape pros made dark spells as a teen 1 of the best in the world at potions, dark arts, and occlumency he is very talented at legilimency has almost nothing you can emotionally imbalance with he arguably has the largest arsenal o. It wasnt necessary that he was dueling 3 different people it was more he was dueling 3 people in unison. He was fighting for dear life and when sprout, slughorn and flitwick came, he. Professor mcgonagalls most memorable moments wizarding. Minerva mcgonagall raises harry potter works archive. Readers will know that snape is portrayed as a bully in early books.
Whos better at duel between these two harry potter characters. The sacking of severus snape wikibooks, open books for an open. Rowling fought for mcgonagalls fight theres an apparate for that. Sure, he was scary and a little biased, but nothing like how he was in the book. Harry is desperate to find the ravenclaw horcrux, and hufflepuffs cup must still be. Minerva mcgonagall overpowers severus snape and forces him to abandons. Minerva mcgonagall in harry potter and the halfblood prince. So i agree that movie snape was, at least to some degree, kinder or with less ill intent. A moment of brilliance by snape that i did not realize at first skip to 19 seconds. A moment of brilliance by snape that i did not realize at first skip to. The sacking of severus snape wikibooks, open books for. I just like the interactions like this from the books. Tell them how you looked him in the eye, a man who trusted you and. Who would win a duel between severus snape and minerva.
Minerva mcgonagall harry potter the last few scenes from the movie involving her made cry so hard. Rowling fought for mcgonagalls battle the mary sue. It doesnt take anyone a full minute to close a book, put that book in a back pack and walk out a door. Mcgonagall vs snape, a harry potter fanfic fanfiction. He does however, choose to leave a small patch of it behind, because he thinks it is a good bit of magic and a tribute to the weasley twins. Her hair had come undone from the battle and she had a gash on her cheek. Severus snape has reprised his role as a spy amongst the death eaters, passing information to his colleagues at great personal risk. After his death at the hands of her own colleague snape for reasons she didnt realise at the time, we cant even fathom how horrendous hogwarts must have been during harrys wouldhavebeen final year. Mcgonagall steps up to the plate after seeing that the dursleys are unfit to be guardians to a magical child. He was fighting for dear life and when sprout, slughorn and flitwick came, he had to flee.
This was the story where our hero had to confront the villains of his past. The bathroom ginny weasley is referring to is actually moaning myrtles lavatory, which readers should remember contains the entrance to the chamber of secrets and that only someone speaking parseltongue can open. The book fell into harrys hands, and that book is filled with amendments to the potion directions. Headmaster severus snape vs professor mcgonagall in hd.
An archive of our own, a project of the organization for transformative works. And the spells snape invented or discovered are also in that book. The harry potter books from severus snapes perspective. They both become headmaster and headmistress someday, and mcgonagall is older than snape seeing as when snape was in school mcgonagall was still deputy headmistress, but snape too, is very skilled and learned from lord voldemort. Camera pulls back, professor severus snape stands at his desk, newspaper in hand as me, harry and ron stare with dread.
With their wands in his free hand, snape tied professor mcgonagall up with a swift incarcerous and stunned luna, letting her fall to the floor. It would be a close duel, but mcgonagall would emerge victorious. The sacking of severus snape is the title of chapter 30 of the seventh book. As the story reaches a critical stage, time is running out.
Boasting magical knowledge and abilities second only to dumbledore. Below the fold a photo shows harry, amy and lockhart at flourish and blotts. Harry raised by mcgonagall as seen by short drabbles through out the years as harry matures. People tend to forget that since shes not a target of fandom lust. Yeah, i get that snape is a badass, but so is mcgonagall. The sacking of severus snape chapter 1, a harry potter.
Harry potter and the deathly hallows severus snape vs minerva. Also i think mcgonagall is underrated and a lot lot more powerful than she lets on. The ousting of severus snape also improperly referred to as the sacking of severus snape was a duel between severus snape, then headmaster of hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry, and the hogwarts heads of houses. Alan rickman played a really strict, feared teacher, but wasnt that bad. She may have played the supporting character a lot during the books, but this chapter gave us mcgonagall s crowning moment. The series focuses much more on severus snape s magical prowess and his mastery of occlumency which is amazing, but very little information is av.
Some direct capture of me playing harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2 on pc. Who would win a duel between severus snape and bellatrix. He bullies students to the verge of tears, is blatantly biased towards slytherins. About snape, i did wonder what he must have been thinking when he was being overthrown. Surely she would be a better gaurdian to a recent orphan than those people.
Mcgonagall, and she said that, in a real fight between the two of them, mcgonagall would win. However, they have radically different personalities and approaches to life. And this is not the book, but the movie where we these things have been highlighted. Books im rereading order of the phoenix and just finished the career advice chapter where harry tells mcgonagall that he might want to become an auror. Part 2 instead of mcgonagall, who fought snape in the book. Quotes badass boss harry potter 41 new ideas minerva see more. Im gonna go with snape, who invented several deadly or nonverbal hexes and spells and practices legillimency. Collected poems mcgonagall, william topaz, mcgonagall, william on. These are just some of the parts that make up the wonderful whole that is professor mcgonagall, and what better way to pay tribute to her brilliance than a. In the book, minerva mcgonagall is the one who does it and for me it. Voldemortno horcruxes vs severus snape battles comic.
Young fans can collect each of their favorite characters for even more fun and expanded play. Mcgonagall says as she rounded a corner and spotted snape in front of the gargoyle that guards the entrance to the headmasters office. Filch lurks in the doorway, eying them with pleasure. We have no evidence that mcgonagall was as talented. As you know, for the majority of the books professor mcgonagall. I cant help but laugh any time mcgonagall gives umbridge. What does the duel between snape and mcgonagall reveal.
I think mcgonagall has a mastery of established magic, whereas snape was an innovator who invented and innovated spells and potions. Harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2 minerva vs. As you know, for the majority of the books professor mcgonagall gracefully played second fiddle to albus dumbledores headmaster. Snape kept his wand to lunas throat and reached out with his other hand for harrys wand, shifting slightly to keep luna in front of him while he moved. Snape vs mcgonagall discussion given the fact that snape was holding back while mcgonagall was going all out, and flitwick needed to join the duel, id say it was heavily implied that snape would have beat mcgonagall if he was actually trying to kill her. It is unknown yet why ron and hermione would have gone there, or if they could open the chamber, but this will play a significant role in the next chapter. Our headmaster is taking a short break, said professor mcgonagall, pointing at the snape shaped.
In deathly hallows part two we see them duel, but just looks like snape is only. The book snape was a complete jerk with no care for whats right and wrong. The daughter of dumbledore and mcgonagall book 2 parents lecture. Having defeated alecto and amycus carrow on the ravenclaw tower. Fans notice another amazing detail about how professor snape. Sirius black, remus lupin, peter pettigrew and james potter the bullies of snape s youth, with one of them happening to be the man who married the love of his life, lily. Our privacy noticeexplains more about how we use your data, and your rights. I cant help but laugh any time mcgonagall gives umbridge attitude. The chapter that made us fall in love with professor mcgonagall. Snape was one of the bravest wizards in the harry potter series. Harry potter and dumbledores army break into hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry to confront professor snape. Seeing here going thru so much emotions is amazing. Nothing in the books or movies imply snape is on the same level. How was voldemort dueling mcgonagall, kingsley and.
Mcgonagall screaming at snape that he was a coward or this beautiful oneliner when snape fled the castle. Minerva mcgonagallseverus snape works archive of our own. He is an exceptionally skilful wizard whose coldly sarcastic and controlled exterior conceals. Mcgonagall is shown to have a strong offense in fact it nearly overwhelmed snape in the book. She has always been a strong woman and her loyalty has never waivered. The chapter that made us fall in love with professor. Albus dumbledore, severus snape, and minerva mcgonagall are some of the most powerful and wellrespected professors hogwarts has ever seen. Near the end of halfblood prince, flitwick is sent by professor mcgonagall to ask professor snape to come to the aid of the order of the phoenix against the intruding death eaters.